Cheeca Lodge & Spa vs Nearby Hotels
Considering Cheeca Lodge & Spa but want to compare other hotels nearby? These guides show how Cheeca Lodge & Spa stacks up against popular alternatives.
Updated · 19 comparisons
All 19 Cheeca Lodge & Spa Comparisons

Cheeca Lodge & Spa vs Hawks Cay Resort
Cheeca Lodge & Spa: five-star Islamorada beachfront resort with pier, golf and a full-service spa. Hawks Cay Resort: a larger family resort in Marathon with pools, marina and villas.
Compare →
Cheeca Lodge & Spa vs Playa Largo Resort & Spa, Autograph Collection
Cheeca Lodge & Spa (Islamorada) vs Playa Largo Resort & Spa (Key Largo): classic Islamorada resort with long private beach and pier versus Autograph Collection waterfront resort in Key Largo.
Compare →
Cheeca Lodge & Spa vs Baker's Cay Resort Key Largo, Curio Collection
Compare Cheeca Lodge & Spa (Islamorada) with Baker's Cay Resort Key Largo (Curio Collection) — beachfront resorts with different Keys locations and strengths.
Compare →
Cheeca Lodge & Spa vs Amara Cay Resort
Compare Cheeca Lodge & Spa (full-service luxury with private beach and pier) and Amara Cay Resort (stylish beach-club vibe) to decide the right Islamorada stay.
Compare →
Cheeca Lodge & Spa vs La Siesta Resort & Villas
Compare Cheeca Lodge & Spa (full-service luxury resort) with La Siesta Resort & Villas (villa-style waterfront cottages) in Islamorada.
Compare →
Cheeca Lodge & Spa vs Three Waters Resort and Marina, Islamorada, a Tribute Portfolio Resort
Cheeca Lodge & Spa: classic beachfront family resort with a big spa; Three Waters: Marriott Tribute with a marina and meeting capacity.
Compare →
Cheeca Lodge & Spa vs Casa Morada
Casa Morada — boutique Matecumbe hotel for quieter, adults-focused stays with two pools and easy access to local dining.
Compare →
Cheeca Lodge & Spa vs Chesapeake Beach Resort
Cheeca Lodge & Spa: full-service luxury resort with beach, spa and family programming; Chesapeake Beach Resort: classic, compact Islamorada beachfront hotel.
Compare →
Cheeca Lodge & Spa vs Grassy Flats Resort & Beach Club
Cheeca Lodge & Spa is an Islamorada luxury resort with private beach and pier; Grassy Flats Resort & Beach Club is a smaller Marathon beach-club property.
Compare →
Cheeca Lodge & Spa vs Lime Tree Bay Resort
Cheeca Lodge & Spa (Islamorada) — five‑star beachfront resort with private beach, pier and full spa
Compare →
Cheeca Lodge & Spa vs Fisher Inn Resort & Marina
Cheeca is a five-star family-friendly resort with a large private beach and full spa; Fisher Inn is a casual marina-side option with dock access and a small beach.
Compare →
Cheeca Lodge & Spa vs Hadley Resort and Marina
Compare Cheeca Lodge & Spa (luxury beachfront resort) with Hadley Resort and Marina (value-minded Islamorada hotel with a marina).
Compare →
Cheeca Lodge & Spa vs Holiday Inn Key Largo
Cheeca Lodge & Spa: five-star Islamorada resort with private beach, multiple restaurants, spa and family activities. Holiday Inn Key Largo: three-star branded hotel with marina access and meeting space.
Compare →
Cheeca Lodge & Spa vs Hampton Inn Key Largo
Cheeca Lodge & Spa: a five‑star Islamorada resort with private beach, spa and wide family amenities. Hampton Inn Key Largo: a branded, bayfront Key Largo hotel close to John Pennekamp.
Compare →
Cheeca Lodge & Spa vs Courtyard
Cheeca Lodge & Spa (Islamorada) vs Courtyard by Marriott Key Largo — resort luxury with beach and spa vs Marriott practicality on the water.
Compare →
Cheeca Lodge & Spa vs Bayside Inn Key Largo
Cheeca Lodge & Spa: luxury beachfront resort in Islamorada. Bayside Inn Key Largo: casual bayside hotel near reef access.
Compare →
Cheeca Lodge & Spa vs Gilbert's Resort
Cheeca Lodge & Spa — Islamorada luxury resort with private beach, spa and family programming.
Compare →
Cheeca Lodge & Spa vs Amoray Dive Resort
Cheeca Lodge & Spa: five-star Islamorada resort with private beach, multiple pools and a full spa; Amoray Dive Resort: compact, dive-focused Key Largo property for dive-centric trips.
Compare →
Cheeca Lodge & Spa vs Marina Del Mar Resort and Marina
Cheeca Lodge & Spa — luxury beachfront resort in Islamorada; Marina Del Mar Resort and Marina — casual Key Largo marina hotel.
Compare →Resort fee includes on-site amenities
- Lowest rate guarantee
- Complimentary perks & upgrades
- 24/7 concierge